The Pursuit of Ecstasy: Theorizing Ṭarab in the Arab Diaspora
Issa Aji
Abstract
This dissertation examines the Arab concept of ṭarab through the words and lived experiences of Arab Americans. It combines music analysis with ethnographic fieldwork to show how ṭarab—understood as both a heightened state of affective engagement (often translated into English as “musical ecstasy”) and an urban style of twentieth-century “art music”—shapes narratives of self-making across the diaspora, serving especially as a vehicle for nostalgia and social solidarity. Drawing on methods and concepts from music studies, social anthropology, affect theory, and gesture studies, I argue that Arab music’s melodic (maqāmāt) and rhythmic (īqāʿāt) modal systems function as sites of kinesthetic potential that, in turn, enable Arab Americans to articulate belonging and/or resistance through participatory expressive gestures associated with ṭarab and its broader socio-cultural milieu.
Over the course of three chapter, I make two central interventions in studying the relationship between ṭarab and the expressively moving body in the Arab diaspora. Chapter 1 explores what I call “rhythmic-temporal disruptions” (RTDs)—a particularly ubiquitous musical phenomenon that involves altering listeners’ temporal experience through frequent (and often sudden) shifts in rhythmic mode (īqāʿ) and tempo. I argue that rhythmic-temporal disruptions function as an embodied practice steeped in kinesthetic memory, rendering nostalgia a particularly accessible emotion for those among the diaspora. Chapter 2 turns to the melodic domain of Arab music, the maqāmāt, where I mount an argument for conceptualizing the maqām system as a network of potential “pathways” among related tetrachords (ajnās). I show how these networks function as spaces of both sonic and gestural potential, and how diasporic listeners engage them to express cultural belonging through shared bodily movement. Chapter 3 then synthesizes the two approaches developed in previous chapters to provide an analytical case study of a ṭarab performance drawn from my fieldwork in Dearborn, Michigan.